Marshall Fine Movies for Smart People Hollywood and Fine
 
Home        Reviews        Interviews        My Books        Bio        Mission Statement        Blog
 
 
Reviews
 
 

November 5, 2009

‘Precious’: Despair – and hope

Part of the magic of movies is their ability to take you places you otherwise couldn’t – or wouldn’t – take yourself.

 

From the fantasy realm of extraterrestrial adventures to the life-and-death setting of a battlefield, film can teach us about ourselves by allowing us to experience the lives of others.

 

The advance hype on the clumsily titled “Precious: Based on the Novel Push by Sapphire” may already have convinced some that this film takes them places they don’t want to go, that it is an experience to avoid – a look into a world of which they want no part. But Lee Daniels’ film is a searing emotional experience, with a note of hope to leaven its sense of despair. It’s solid, imaginative filmmaking, to boot.

 

Granted, describing the film’s central character, Claireece Precious Jones (Gabourey Sidibe), is already almost a deal-breaker for many filmgoers. As the film begins, Claireece is an obese, illiterate, abused high-school dropout, pregnant with her second child. The film is set in the early 1980s, the cruel days of the Reagan era, which means Claireece is clearly in danger of becoming another poverty statistic, a forgotten person at the mercy of an overwhelmed social-welfare system – a life that’s seemingly over before it’s begun.

 

But she is saved by the principal of the school that expels her, who suggests an alternative school. There, for the first time, Claireece receives attention from someone who sees her for her potential, rather than as a space-filler or a nuisance. That teacher, Ms. Rain (Paula Patton), challenges Claireece to better herself, to learn to read and write, and does it in a way that pulls Claireece from the pit her life has become.

 

But it’s not easy, because Precious is being pulled back down daily by her mother, Mary (Mo’Nique). Abuse begets abuse and though we don’t know Mary’s story, we can feel it from the way she treats her daughter. She uses Claireece as her slave and punching bag, to give herself the illusion of power or control in a life where she has little of either.

 

There isn’t much more plot than that: one teenager’s struggle to take control of her life and overcome odds that are, at minimum, daunting. This is a film that doesn’t shy away from the depths to which human beings can sink, but it also shows the strength and resilience of which we are capable, even at our lowest moments.

 

Daniels contrasts the grim reality of Claireece’s life with the sparkly teen-age, media-fueled fantasies into which she escapes. In Geoffrey Fletcher’s beautifully wrought script, these are sometimes funny, sometimes jarring, a device that adds poignancy to the reality Claireece is trying to escape.

 

The anchor of the film is Sidibe’s performance as Claireece. This newcomer begins as guarded and inarticulate; but she opens up, revealing a soul and consciousness that blossom under even the slightest approval or affection.

 

The other revelation in this film is Mo’Nique, a raucous stand-up comic who disappears into the role of this cruelly abusive mother. Mary could easily be portrayed as a straight-up monster, but Mo’Nique takes it deeper than that. She finds the fear and powerlessness that drive Mary to dominate and mistreat her daughter. She once was Claireece – and hates herself and her daughter for it as a result. Mo’Nique already is being mentioned as Oscar material – and rightly so.

 

One other casting note: As a critic who verbally dismantled Mariah Carey’s acting in the misbegotten “Glitter” almost a decade ago, I take my hat off to her work here as a tough, weary social worker. Though I saw her name in the opening credits, I didn’t recognize her in this gritty performance – and had to be told it was her afterwards.

 

Strong emotions make some critics uneasy; they consider them cheap and manipulative, which they can be, though that doesn’t describe this movie. Some already have attacked “Precious” for that, but it says more about the critic than the film.

 

“Precious” is a powerful social drama telling a gripping personal story. It will put you through the wringer and take your breath away at times – but it is too solid, too true, too real to miss.

 

Print This Post Print This Post

Share/Save/Bookmark

 


4 Responses to “‘Precious’: Despair – and hope”

  1. tiana Says:

    I’m so going to see this movie!!!!!!!

  2. James Guilford Says:

    After seeing an advance screening Daniels’ “Precious” two weeks ago, I’m still moved. “Prescious” is unrelentingly tragic. For 109 minutes—a good portion of which are set in a dim, dingy, dime-sized apartment—I plunged down and down and down into the pain of Precious’ life. And just when I thought I (and Precious) had hit rock bottom—whoosh!—the bottom opened up and swallowed me whole. Until I saw Sidibe in interview, I was not necessarily astounded by her performance. But the transition she made from her usually bright and bubble self (a self which comes across clearly in interviews) to the despondent Precious is astounding. By far, the most outstanding performance is Mo’Nique as Mary, Precious’ mother. From her utterance of her first insult to Precious, the audience knows that comedian Mo’Nique has been inhabited by a actress of Meryl Streep caliber. Monique’s delivery of Mary is so thoroughly convincing that it is an injustice to call her execution a performance.

    - James Guilford

  3. Mariana Boneo Says:

    Marshall,
    I confess that though I read about this film I probably wasn’t going to see it. This kind of stories make us wonder..Am I in the mood for this?
    I am grateful to have been exposed to Precious. Though bleak a subject it brings a confirmation that hope comes in different forms and when there is openness to change paths what initially was a dead end can be part of a journey.
    An interesting exploration on character, love’s power and how beauty can be found in unexpected places.

  4. Alisha Says:

    As an African American activist..I wonder if any of the work does any good. Irevel in the time, when black women will begiven roles which showcases both their incredible acting abilities, and also true black women. Stereotypes still do exist within black communities; however do we have to have it PUSHED into our faces by the condemned ‘Sapphire’ black stereotype. It’s not just about the hardships..for once I would like to see AA women portrayed honestly, and not stereotypically. It’s hard to watch with no explanation, but when Tupac sang it(because he was angry, and told the truth), In Brenda’s got a baby..no one listened. So now..you listen? When AA women are at the height of being at the heads of their families, and AA single mothers are finally just gaining respect?

    I don’t know. It’s hard to believe that you pay no attention to the good that we do; until it’sbeneficial to you. But…when it’s not..when we are not, we are Sapphire, Aunt Jemima, Mamie, crackhead,abusive mother & every other convenient stereotype. I understand that she is trying to help,by showing one scenario within the AA community; that was negative, and has a positive outcome..but statistically it doesn’t even make sense to use an AA woman. We are actually ahead of the game education wise.. Oh well, I guess I’ll log this in with Sandra Bullock (white);in her new movie..adopting some poor lonely black homeless teen. Whatever. I have yet to get congratulations on my child’s adoption. Perhaps..it’s because I’m walking in someone’sconstant threatening shadow. LOL

Leave a Reply

 

Subscribe via RSS

Subscribe to
Reviews via Email



blog advertising
is good for you



 

 
 
© 2009 - hollywoodandfine.com - All Rights Reserved -  - Legal - Site Map - designed by FirstCrescent